The workplace comedy has evolved over the years from a true situation-based environment to more creative surroundings, which bring with them genre enhancements, like a good underlying mystery to drive forward the inherently funny things that happen. Mike Schur has been a part of that transformation, creating Parks and Recreation and Brooklyn Nine-Nine before expanding to The Good Place and A Man on the Inside, which both take comedic actors and put them in unexpected places where they’re investigating something while trying to find happiness and just get through the day. His latest, which he co-created with his wife J.J. Philbin, follows that same template, bringing another worthwhile and extremely entertaining story to the small screen.
Dig, more than anything, is about female empowerment and friendship, centering on Elise (Amy Poehler), who is second-in-command at an archeological dig site in Greece, forever in the shadow of her eternally-retiring boss Neville (Hugh Laurie). As another summer with college students begins, Elise makes an unexpected discovery and sets out to claim it for herself rather than defer credit to Neville as usual. Nothing stays secret for long, and her tentative circle of trust soon includes loose cannon Dylan (Geraldine Viswanathan), straight-laced Clare (Antonia Thomas), and socially-challenged Patty (Fina Strazza).
Like A Man on the Inside, this comedy series has unconventional source material, in this case the novel Excavations by Kate Myers. Anyone who has ever watched and enjoyed Parks and Recreation will celebrate the reunion of Schur and Poehler, but they shouldn’t expect Poehler to be playing another version of Leslie Knope. While Elise does indeed put in as much effort and always picks up the slack for any supervisor, colleague, or underling who isn’t willing to do their share, she’s much more pessimistic about the world. She isn’t able to hide the crushing, debilitating frustration that follows her around, most evident when she attempts to welcome the new students and ends up being upstaged entirely by an effortlessly charming Neville, whose British accent seems enough to make even the laziest member of the dig spring to attention.
It’s fun to see Laurie in this role, which fits him like a glove and allows him to be generally happier than some of his most iconic parts, like House and Avenue 5, have found him in the past. But the true find here is the remaining trio in the ensemble. Viswanathan, whose main TV experience is the underrated anthology series Miracle Workers, leans into Dylan’s chaos, making her somehow endearing despite deliberately failing to adhere to societal norms and even the most basic behavioral expectations. Thomas, a British actress who starred in The Good Doctor, finds the humor in a character who could be buttoned-up and rigid, and it’s wondrous to see her slowly let loose. Strazza, whose main claim to fame is being the youngest Matilda on Broadway, does a remarkable job of making a truly unbelievable character, plucked right out of an irreverent world like Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt, feel so real and fantastic.
This top-tier cast anchors an immersive half-hour comedy that gradually builds tension and deepens its core mystery while always staying focused on the laughs. Kayvan Novak and Jason Mantzoukas have memorable guest roles, enhancing a superb ensemble whose members are all fully aware of the tone and vibe of this show. It’s more serious – but takes itself less seriously – than A Man on the Inside, and while it might not yet be in the same league as Parks and Recreation or Brooklyn Nine-Nine in terms of its quotability and very specific characters, it’s on track to get there with a promising start. There’s not too much mental – or time – commitment being asked from this show, which offers refreshing, satisfying entertainment and is certainly worthy of returning for its chance at a place in sitcom history.
Season Rating: 8/10


